Too many small and mid-sized organizations are prime candidates for being victimized by employee fraud.
Here's a typical scenario: The company has delegated all its accounting and reporting duties to its internal CFO, controller, or chief accountant. No oversight is placed over this individual. That's all it takes. The trusted and capable manager now has the opportunity to steal from the company and then cover-up things via "creative" accounting.
I've seen it way too many times, usually when the victim company or its attorney calls me in to help quantify the damage and to assist with the criminal or civil litigation. I imagine you've observed the same in your practice.
How can we, as solo accountants, help clients protect themselves from embezzlement by their opportunistic, dishonest financial managers. Here's an idea: Propose an ongoing monthly or quarterly engagement in which you're retained to perform various antifraud-oriented services such as the following:
- Obtain and read the current and prior period financial statements and information submitted to your client by the financial manager. Compare this with the reports you receive directly from the financial manager, then ask for the underlying general ledger, subsidiary ledgers, account reconciliations, bank statements, cancelled checks, payroll tax returns, and support for all general journal entries.
- Scan the the summary and detailed information, looking for anything unusual. Make a list of these items as well as various questions, that when asked of the financial manager, let them know that a trained professional is looking at their work. An example of such a question might be, "Why is the balance in accounts receivable on your month-end financial statement so much larger than the figure shown on the detail aging report?"
- Hold periodic Q&A sessions with the financial manager, sometimes on a surprise basis. Ask them about the items on the listing you prepared in the previous step. Be extra alert for any responses that don't appear reasonable and/or body language which might indicate deception. Follow-up these observations as agreed-to by you and your client. Report all significant findings to the client.
If nothing else, these procedures should send a loud, clear message to the potential fraudster that should he or she embezzle from their employee, there's now a higher chance their misdeeds might be detected. This alone will tend to deter them from stepping over the bounds of right behavior.
How such an engagement is communicated to the financial manager, and how you interact with the individual as the work is conducted will impact the attitude and level of cooperation of the manager. Depending on the situation, the business owners might simply tell the manager, "To help us strengthen our internal controls, we've retained an outside expert to provide another set of eyes and ears over various aspects of the business, including the accounting area." Tactfulness is important, so as to not convey a lack of trust or confidence in the finance manager.
Don't forget to spell out all aspects of the assignment in a well-written engagement letter to be signed by you and the client. There's no way you can prevent or detect all fraud that might exist in your client's operation, so be sure to include adequate disclaimers in the letter.
Recent Comments